Discover

When I first booted up the new Top Spin game, I was genuinely excited to dive back into a franchise I'd loved for years. That initial excitement, however, was quickly tempered by a sense of déjà vu that soon morphed into disappointment. The central experience, the MyCareer mode, is polished and engaging, but the moment you step outside of it, the game world feels startlingly empty. The options outside of MyCareer are, to put it bluntly, extremely barebones. As someone who has spent countless hours with various sports sims, this lack of content is impossible to ignore. It's a stark contrast to the rich ecosystems found in other titles, and it raises questions about the long-term viability of this particular launch.

Now, I do want to be fair. This release is effectively a fresh launch for the Top Spin series after a nearly decade-long hiatus. In that context, some leeway is warranted. The developers, 2K, likely focused their resources on nailing the core gameplay and the MyCareer experience first, which they have largely succeeded in doing. The tennis itself feels fantastic—the weight of the shots, the player movement, the strategic depth on the court is arguably the best the series has ever seen. But here’s the thing: in 2024, a sports game is judged as much by its surrounding features as it is by its on-field action. We, as players, have been conditioned to expect a suite of modes. We want to be able to jump into a deep franchise management sim, create wild custom tournaments with friends, or engage in some kind of persistent online club competition. Top Spin offers none of that. When I look at the landscape, the comparison that immediately springs to my mind is NBA 2K, another 2K sports title. That franchise, for all its microtransaction controversies, is a content behemoth. It has MyCareer, MyTeam, The Neighborhood, MyNBA, and a dozen other ways to play. The disparity is just massive. I’d estimate that NBA 2K has over 85% more gameplay modes outside of its career equivalent. That’s not a minor gap; it’s a chasm.

So, what exactly is there to do outside of the career grind? The answer is disappointingly simple. Local play is limited to a basic list for single and doubles exhibition games, and the Top Spin Academy tutorials. That’s pretty much it. You can pick a player, pick a court, and play a match. There’s no tournament bracket creator, no season mode, no narrative-driven exhibition scenarios. It feels like a framework waiting to be filled with content. The Top Spin Academy is narrated by the legendary John McEnroe, and his voice certainly adds a layer of authenticity. The tutorials themselves are a good, even great, overview of how to play the game. For a complete newcomer, spending an hour in the Academy is essential to understanding the timing-based swing mechanics and strategic nuances. But its value is almost entirely front-loaded. After you’ve run through it once, maybe twice to refine a specific skill, there's zero reason to ever go back. There’s no progressive challenge, no dynamic training modules that adapt to your weaknesses. It’s a static feature, and in a game that’s already light on features, that static nature becomes a glaring weakness.

This situation creates a specific problem for a player like me. I adore the core tennis loop. I’ve probably played over 150 exhibition matches just for the sheer joy of it. But without goals, without structure, even the most satisfying gameplay can start to feel repetitive. I find myself wishing for a simple ladder system, or a "rivalry" mode where I could face off against a curated list of AI opponents with specific strengths. The foundation is so strong, yet the house built upon it feels unfinished. I can't help but think this was a deliberate, if unfortunate, business decision. By keeping the feature set lean at launch, 2K reserves the ability to add more modes in a sequel or as premium DLC down the line, a common tactic in today's gaming industry. But for the consumer who drops, let's say, a full $70 on this game, the value proposition becomes harder to justify based on content volume alone.

Ultimately, my relationship with this new Top Spin is one of conflicted admiration. I admire its technical prowess and the clear passion that went into perfecting the feel of tennis. The matches are tense, strategic, and immensely rewarding. Yet, I’m constantly frustrated by the lack of a complete package. It’s a game with a brilliant heart but underdeveloped limbs. For the hardcore tennis fan who just wants to play match after match, it might be enough. But for the modern sports gamer, accustomed to a buffet of options and long-term engagement hooks, this offering feels more like a tantalizing appetizer than a main course. The potential for a truly legendary tennis sim is all here, simmering just below the surface, waiting for a future update or iteration to fully realize it. For now, I’ll keep playing my exhibition matches, dreaming of the robust feature set that could have been.